X-Git-Url: http://git.tdb.fi/?p=libs%2Fgl.git;a=blobdiff_plain;f=source%2Fcore%2Fmodule.cpp;h=5475e434ac2636331c846a529bdf99fb508efb04;hp=374ef8ae4d71537fcfa36b37cdba910e63b7faf9;hb=HEAD;hpb=70d9d2d28e5fe723c6b46894276e4c935f578e2d diff --git a/source/core/module.cpp b/source/core/module.cpp index 374ef8ae..04a37fcc 100644 --- a/source/core/module.cpp +++ b/source/core/module.cpp @@ -1,4 +1,6 @@ +#include #include +#include "device.h" #include "module.h" #include "resources.h" @@ -12,6 +14,7 @@ enum SpirVConstants OP_NAME = 5, OP_MEMBER_NAME = 6, OP_ENTRY_POINT = 15, + OP_EXECUTION_MODE = 16, OP_TYPE_VOID = 19, OP_TYPE_BOOL = 20, OP_TYPE_INT = 21, @@ -30,12 +33,29 @@ enum SpirVConstants OP_SPEC_CONSTANT_FALSE = 49, OP_SPEC_CONSTANT = 50, OP_VARIABLE = 59, + OP_LOAD = 61, + OP_STORE = 62, + OP_ACCESS_CHAIN = 65, OP_DECORATE = 71, OP_MEMBER_DECORATE = 72, + OP_COPY_OBJECT = 83, + OP_PHI = 245, + OP_SELECTION_MERGE = 247, + OP_LABEL = 248, + OP_BRANCH = 249, + OP_BRANCH_CONDITIONAL = 250, + OP_SWITCH = 251, + OP_KILL = 252, + OP_RETURN = 253, + OP_RETURN_VALUE = 254, + OP_UNREACHABLE = 255, + + EXEC_LOCAL_SIZE = 17, DECO_SPEC_ID = 1, DECO_ARRAY_STRIDE = 6, DECO_MATRIX_STRIDE = 7, + DECO_BUILTIN = 11, DECO_LOCATION = 30, DECO_BINDING = 33, DECO_DESCRIPTOR_SET = 34, @@ -47,14 +67,14 @@ namespace GL { void Module::set_source(const string &src) { - SL::Compiler compiler; + SL::Compiler compiler(create_features()); compiler.set_source(src); compile(compiler); } void Module::load_source(IO::Base &io, Resources *res, const string &name) { - SL::Compiler compiler; + SL::Compiler compiler(create_features()); compiler.load_source(io, res, name); compile(compiler); } @@ -64,6 +84,20 @@ void Module::load_source(IO::Base &io, const string &name) load_source(io, 0, name); } +SL::Features Module::create_features() const +{ + const DeviceInfo &dev_info = Device::get_current().get_info(); + const SL::Features &device_features = dev_info.glsl_features; + SL::Features latest_features = SL::Features::latest(dev_info.api); + SL::Features features; + features.target_api = latest_features.target_api; + features.glsl_version = latest_features.glsl_version; + features.constant_id_range = device_features.constant_id_range; + features.uniform_binding_range = device_features.uniform_binding_range; + features.texture_binding_range = device_features.texture_binding_range; + return features; +} + void GlslModule::compile(SL::Compiler &compiler) { @@ -79,44 +113,9 @@ void GlslModule::compile(SL::Compiler &compiler) } -SpirVModule::SpirVModule(const SpirVModule &other): - code(other.code), - entry_points(other.entry_points), - structs(other.structs), - variables(other.variables) -{ - remap_pointers_from(other); -} - -SpirVModule &SpirVModule::operator=(const SpirVModule &other) -{ - code = other.code; - entry_points = other.entry_points; - structs = other.structs; - variables = other.variables; - remap_pointers_from(other); - return *this; -} - -void SpirVModule::remap_pointers_from(const SpirVModule &other) -{ - for(vector::iterator i=entry_points.begin(); i!=entry_points.end(); ++i) - for(vector::iterator j=i->globals.begin(); j!=i->globals.end(); ++j) - *j = &variables[*j-&other.variables.front()]; - - for(vector::iterator i=variables.begin(); i!=variables.end(); ++i) - if(i->struct_type) - i->struct_type = &structs[i->struct_type-&other.structs.front()]; - - for(vector::iterator i=structs.begin(); i!=structs.end(); ++i) - for(vector::iterator j=i->members.begin(); j!=i->members.end(); ++j) - if(j->struct_type) - j->struct_type = &structs[j->struct_type-&other.structs.front()]; -} - void SpirVModule::load_code(IO::Base &io) { - UInt32 buffer[1024]; + uint32_t buffer[1024]; while(1) { unsigned len = io.read(reinterpret_cast(buffer), sizeof(buffer)); @@ -127,13 +126,27 @@ void SpirVModule::load_code(IO::Base &io) code.insert(code.end(), buffer, buffer+len); } + reflect(); + create(); +} + +void SpirVModule::compile(SL::Compiler &compiler) +{ + compiler.compile(SL::Compiler::SPIRV); + code = compiler.get_combined_spirv(); + reflect(); + create(); +} + +void SpirVModule::reflect() +{ if(code.empty()) throw invalid_module("Empty SPIR-V code"); if(code[0]==SPIRV_MAGIC_REVERSED) { - for(vector::iterator i=code.begin(); i!=code.end(); ++i) - *i = ((*i&0xFF)<<24) || ((*i&0xFF00)<<8) | ((*i>>8)&0xFF00) | ((*i>>24)&0xFF); + for(uint32_t &c: code) + c = ((c&0xFF)<<24) || ((c&0xFF00)<<8) | ((c>>8)&0xFF00) | ((c>>24)&0xFF); } else if(code[0]!=SPIRV_MAGIC) throw invalid_module("SPIR-V magic number not found"); @@ -141,26 +154,32 @@ void SpirVModule::load_code(IO::Base &io) Reflection reflection; reflection.reflect_code(code); + map spec_indices; + for(const auto &kvp: reflection.constants) + if(kvp.second.constant_id>=0) + { + spec_indices[&kvp.second] = spec_constants.size(); + spec_constants.push_back(kvp.second); + } + map struct_indices; structs.reserve(reflection.structs.size()); - for(map::const_iterator i=reflection.structs.begin(); i!=reflection.structs.end(); ++i) + for(const auto &kvp: reflection.structs) { - struct_indices[&i->second] = structs.size(); - structs.push_back(i->second); + struct_indices[&kvp.second] = structs.size(); + structs.push_back(kvp.second); } - for(vector::iterator i=structs.begin(); i!=structs.end(); ++i) + for(Structure &s: structs) { - for(vector::iterator j=i->members.begin(); j!=i->members.end(); ++j) - { - if(j->struct_type) + for(StructMember &m: s.members) + if(m.struct_type) { - map::const_iterator k = struct_indices.find(j->struct_type); - j->struct_type = (k!=struct_indices.end() ? &structs[k->second] : 0); + auto i = struct_indices.find(m.struct_type); + m.struct_type = (i!=struct_indices.end() ? &structs[i->second] : 0); } - } - const StructMember *last_member = &i->members.back(); + const StructMember *last_member = &s.members.back(); unsigned last_offset = last_member->offset; while(last_member->struct_type) { @@ -171,79 +190,296 @@ void SpirVModule::load_code(IO::Base &io) last_member = lm; } - i->size = last_offset+get_type_size(last_member->type); - i->size = (i->size+15)&~15; + unsigned last_size = get_type_size(last_member->type); + if(last_member->array_size) + last_size += last_member->array_stride*(last_member->array_size-1); + s.size = last_offset+last_size; + s.size = (s.size+15)&~15; } map var_indices; variables.reserve(reflection.variables.size()); - for(map::const_iterator i=reflection.variables.begin(); i!=reflection.variables.end(); ++i) + for(const auto &kvp: reflection.variables) { - int dup_index = -1; - for(vector::const_iterator j=variables.begin(); (dup_index<0 && j!=variables.end()); ++j) - if(*j==i->second) - dup_index = j-variables.begin(); - - if(dup_index>=0) - var_indices[&i->second] = dup_index; + auto i = find_if(variables, [&kvp](const Variable &v){ return v==kvp.second; }); + if(i!=variables.end()) + var_indices[&kvp.second] = i-variables.begin(); else { - var_indices[&i->second] = variables.size(); - variables.push_back(i->second); + var_indices[&kvp.second] = variables.size(); + variables.push_back(kvp.second); } } - for(vector::iterator i=variables.begin(); i!=variables.end(); ++i) - if(i->struct_type) + for(Variable &v: variables) + if(v.struct_type) { - map::const_iterator j = struct_indices.find(i->struct_type); - i->struct_type = (j!=struct_indices.end() ? &structs[j->second] : 0); + auto i = struct_indices.find(v.struct_type); + v.struct_type = (i!=struct_indices.end() ? &structs[i->second] : 0); } entry_points.reserve(reflection.entry_points.size()); - for(map::const_iterator i=reflection.entry_points.begin(); i!=reflection.entry_points.end(); ++i) + for(const auto &kvp: reflection.entry_points) { - entry_points.push_back(i->second); + entry_points.push_back(kvp.second); EntryPoint &entry = entry_points.back(); - for(vector::iterator j=entry.globals.begin(); j!=entry.globals.end(); ++j) + for(const Variable *&v: entry.globals) { - map::const_iterator k = var_indices.find(*j); - *j = (k!=var_indices.end() ? &variables[k->second] : 0); + auto i = var_indices.find(v); + v = (i!=var_indices.end() ? &variables[i->second] : 0); } } - for(map::const_iterator i=reflection.spec_constants.begin(); i!=reflection.spec_constants.end(); ++i) - spec_constants.push_back(i->second); + map block_indices; + blocks.reserve(reflection.blocks.size()); + for(const auto &kvp: reflection.blocks) + { + block_indices[&kvp.second] = blocks.size(); + blocks.push_back(kvp.second); + } + + for(InstructionBlock &b: blocks) + { + auto i = spec_indices.find(b.condition); + b.condition = (i!=spec_indices.end() ? &spec_constants[i->second] : 0); + if(b.condition) + specializable = true; + + for(const Variable *&v: b.accessed_variables) + { + auto j = var_indices.find(v); + v = (j!=var_indices.end() ? &variables[j->second] : 0); + } + + for(const InstructionBlock *&s: b.successors) + { + auto j = block_indices.find(s); + s = (j!=block_indices.end() ? &blocks[j->second] : 0); + } + } } -void SpirVModule::compile(SL::Compiler &) +SpirVModule *SpirVModule::specialize(const map &spec_values) const { - throw logic_error("Not implemented yet"); + vector flags(code[3], 1); + + std::map spec_values_by_id; + for(const Constant &c: spec_constants) + { + auto i = spec_values.find(c.name); + if(i!=spec_values.end()) + { + flags[c.id] = (i->second ? 5 : 3); + spec_values_by_id[c.constant_id] = i->second; + } + } + + for(const EntryPoint &e: entry_points) + flags[e.id] = 0; + for(const Variable &v: variables) + flags[v.id] = 0; + for(const InstructionBlock &b: blocks) + flags[b.id] = 0; + for(const InstructionBlock *b: collect_visited_blocks(spec_values_by_id)) + { + flags[b->id] = 1; + for(const Variable *v: b->accessed_variables) + flags[v->id] = 1; + } + + std::vector new_code; + new_code.reserve(code.size()); + + auto op = code.begin()+5; + new_code.insert(new_code.begin(), code.begin(), op); + + bool skip_block = false; + while(op!=code.end()) + { + unsigned word_count = *op>>16; + unsigned opcode = *op&0xFFFF; + + bool copy = !skip_block; + if(skip_block) + { + skip_block = (opcode!=OP_BRANCH && opcode!=OP_BRANCH_CONDITIONAL && opcode!=OP_SWITCH && + opcode!=OP_KILL && opcode!=OP_RETURN && opcode!=OP_RETURN_VALUE && opcode!=OP_UNREACHABLE); + } + else + { + if(opcode==OP_NAME) + copy = flags[*(op+1)]; + else if(opcode==OP_ENTRY_POINT) + { + unsigned start = new_code.size(); + new_code.push_back(opcode); + new_code.push_back(*(op+1)); + unsigned func_id = *(op+2); + new_code.push_back(func_id); + + unsigned i = 3; + while(i>24)) + break; + } + + unsigned var_count = 0; + for(; icode = move(new_code); + spec_mod->reflect(); + spec_mod->create(); + + return spec_mod; } +vector SpirVModule::collect_visited_blocks(const map &spec_values) const +{ + vector visited(blocks.size(), 4); + for(unsigned i=0; ii_value; + auto j = spec_values.find(b.condition->constant_id); + if(j!=spec_values.end()) + cond = j->second; + if(b.negate_condition) + cond = !cond; + } + + visited[i] |= cond*2; + for(const InstructionBlock *s: b.successors) + visited[s-blocks.data()] &= 3; + } -SpirVModule::EntryPoint::EntryPoint(): - stage(VERTEX) -{ } + for(unsigned i=0; i result; + for(unsigned i=0; i &visited) const +{ + visited[i] |= 1; + for(const InstructionBlock *s: blocks[i].successors) + { + unsigned j = s-blocks.data(); + if((visited[j]&3)==2) + collect_visited_blocks(j, visited); + } +} -SpirVModule::Variable::Variable(): - type(VOID), - struct_type(0), - location(-1), - descriptor_set(-1), - binding(-1) -{ } bool SpirVModule::Variable::operator==(const Variable &other) const { @@ -257,16 +493,7 @@ bool SpirVModule::Variable::operator==(const Variable &other) const } -SpirVModule::TypeInfo::TypeInfo(): - type(VOID), - struct_type(0), - array_size(0), - array_stride(0), - storage(static_cast(-1)) -{ } - - -UInt32 SpirVModule::Reflection::get_opcode(UInt32 op) +uint32_t SpirVModule::Reflection::get_opcode(uint32_t op) { return op&0xFFFF; } @@ -298,12 +525,12 @@ string SpirVModule::Reflection::read_string(CodeIterator &op, const CodeIterator throw invalid_module("Unterminated SPIR-V string literal"); } -void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_code(const vector &code) +void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_code(const vector &code) { for(CodeIterator op=code.begin()+5; op!=code.end(); ) { unsigned word_count = *op>>16; - if(word_count>code.end()-op) + if(word_count>static_cast(code.end()-op)) throw invalid_module("Truncated SPIR-V instruction"); switch(get_opcode(*op)) @@ -311,26 +538,33 @@ void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_code(const vector &code) case OP_NAME: reflect_name(op); break; case OP_MEMBER_NAME: reflect_member_name(op); break; case OP_ENTRY_POINT: reflect_entry_point(op); break; + case OP_EXECUTION_MODE: reflect_execution_mode(op); break; case OP_TYPE_VOID: reflect_void_type(op); break; case OP_TYPE_BOOL: reflect_bool_type(op); break; case OP_TYPE_INT: reflect_int_type(op); break; case OP_TYPE_FLOAT: reflect_float_type(op); break; case OP_TYPE_VECTOR: reflect_vector_type(op); break; - case OP_TYPE_MATRIX: reflect_vector_type(op); break; + case OP_TYPE_MATRIX: reflect_matrix_type(op); break; case OP_TYPE_IMAGE: reflect_image_type(op); break; case OP_TYPE_SAMPLED_IMAGE: reflect_sampled_image_type(op); break; case OP_TYPE_ARRAY: reflect_array_type(op); break; case OP_TYPE_STRUCT: reflect_struct_type(op); break; case OP_TYPE_POINTER: reflect_pointer_type(op); break; - case OP_CONSTANT_TRUE: constants[*(op+2)] = true; break; - case OP_CONSTANT_FALSE: constants[*(op+2)] = false; break; - case OP_CONSTANT: reflect_constant(op); break; + case OP_CONSTANT_TRUE: + case OP_CONSTANT_FALSE: + case OP_CONSTANT: case OP_SPEC_CONSTANT_TRUE: case OP_SPEC_CONSTANT_FALSE: - case OP_SPEC_CONSTANT: reflect_spec_constant(op); break; + case OP_SPEC_CONSTANT: reflect_constant(op); break; case OP_VARIABLE: reflect_variable(op); break; + case OP_LOAD: + case OP_STORE: reflect_access(op); break; + case OP_ACCESS_CHAIN: reflect_access_chain(op); break; case OP_DECORATE: reflect_decorate(op); break; case OP_MEMBER_DECORATE: reflect_member_decorate(op); break; + case OP_LABEL: reflect_label(op); break; + case OP_BRANCH: reflect_branch(op); break; + case OP_BRANCH_CONDITIONAL: reflect_branch_conditional(op); break; } op += word_count; @@ -359,7 +593,9 @@ void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_member_name(CodeIterator op) void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_entry_point(CodeIterator op) { CodeIterator op_end = get_op_end(op); - EntryPoint &entry = entry_points[*(op+2)]; + unsigned id = *(op+2); + EntryPoint &entry = entry_points[id]; + entry.id = id; entry.stage = static_cast(*(op+1)); // Execution model in SPIR-V spec op += 3; entry.name = read_string(op, op_end); @@ -369,6 +605,18 @@ void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_entry_point(CodeIterator op) entry.globals.push_back(&variables[*op]); } +void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_execution_mode(CodeIterator op) +{ + EntryPoint &entry = entry_points[*(op+1)]; + unsigned mode = *(op+2); + if(mode==EXEC_LOCAL_SIZE) + { + entry.compute_local_size.x = *(op+3); + entry.compute_local_size.y = *(op+4); + entry.compute_local_size.z = *(op+5); + } +} + void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_void_type(CodeIterator op) { types[*(op+1)].type = VOID; @@ -399,7 +647,7 @@ void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_vector_type(CodeIterator op) TypeInfo &type = types[*(op+1)]; DataType component = types[*(op+2)].type; unsigned count = *(op+3); - type.type = static_cast((count<<12) | (component&0xF00) | ((component&0xFF)*count)); + type.type = static_cast(((count-1)<<12) | (component&0xF00) | ((component&0xFF)*count)); } void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_matrix_type(CodeIterator op) @@ -407,17 +655,19 @@ void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_matrix_type(CodeIterator op) TypeInfo &type = types[*(op+1)]; DataType column = types[*(op+2)].type; unsigned count = *(op+3); - type.type = static_cast((count<<16) | (column&0xF00) | ((column&0xFF)*count)); + type.type = static_cast(((count-1)<<14) | (column&0x3F00) | ((column&0xFF)*count)); } void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_image_type(CodeIterator op) { TypeInfo &type = types[*(op+1)]; - DataType sample = types[*(op+2)].type; + DataType sample_type = types[*(op+2)].type; unsigned dimensions = *(op+3); bool depth = *(op+4)==1; bool array = *(op+5); - type.type = static_cast((depth*0x200000) | (array*0x80000) | (dimensions+1) | sample); + bool sampled = *(op+7)==1; + type.type = static_cast((depth*0x200000) | (sampled*0x100000) | (array*0x80000) | + ((dimensions+1)<<16) | sample_type); } void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_sampled_image_type(CodeIterator op) @@ -433,11 +683,10 @@ void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_array_type(CodeIterator op) const TypeInfo &elem = types[*(op+2)]; type.type = elem.type; type.struct_type = elem.struct_type; - const Variant &size = constants[*(op+3)]; - if(size.check_type()) - type.array_size = size.value(); - else if(size.check_type()) - type.array_size = size.value(); + + const Constant &size = constants[*(op+3)]; + if(size.type==INT || size.type==UNSIGNED_INT) + type.array_size = size.i_value; } void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_struct_type(CodeIterator op) @@ -446,11 +695,12 @@ void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_struct_type(CodeIterator op) unsigned id = *(op+1); Structure &strct = structs[id]; strct.name = names[id]; + strct.id = id; types[id].struct_type = &strct; op += 2; strct.members.resize(op_end-op); - vector::iterator mem = strct.members.begin(); + auto mem = strct.members.begin(); for(; op!=op_end; ++op, ++mem) { TypeInfo &type = types[*op]; @@ -470,22 +720,20 @@ void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_pointer_type(CodeIterator op) void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_constant(CodeIterator op) { - const TypeInfo &type = types[*(op+1)]; - unsigned id = *(op+2); - if(type.type==INT) - constants[id] = static_cast(*(op+3)); - else if(type.type==UNSIGNED_INT) - constants[id] = static_cast(*(op+3)); - else if(type.type==FLOAT) - constants[id] = *reinterpret_cast(&*(op+3)); -} - -void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_spec_constant(CodeIterator op) -{ + unsigned opcode = get_opcode(*op); unsigned id = *(op+2); - SpecConstant &spec = spec_constants[id]; - spec.name = names[id]; - spec.type = types[*(op+1)].type; + Constant &cnst = constants[id]; + cnst.name = names[id]; + cnst.id = id; + cnst.type = types[*(op+1)].type; + if(opcode==OP_CONSTANT_TRUE || opcode==OP_SPEC_CONSTANT_TRUE) + cnst.i_value = true; + else if(opcode==OP_CONSTANT_FALSE || opcode==OP_SPEC_CONSTANT_FALSE) + cnst.i_value = false; + else if(cnst.type==INT || cnst.type==UNSIGNED_INT) + cnst.i_value = *(op+3); + else if(cnst.type==FLOAT) + cnst.f_value = *reinterpret_cast(&*(op+3)); } void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_variable(CodeIterator op) @@ -493,6 +741,7 @@ void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_variable(CodeIterator op) unsigned id = *(op+2); Variable &var = variables[id]; var.name = names[id]; + var.id = id; const TypeInfo &type = types[*(op+1)]; var.storage = type.storage; var.type = type.type; @@ -500,6 +749,26 @@ void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_variable(CodeIterator op) var.array_size = type.array_size; } +void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_access(CodeIterator op) +{ + if(current_block) + { + unsigned id = (get_opcode(*op)==OP_LOAD ? *(op+3) : *(op+1)); + auto i = access_chain_bases.find(id); + if(i!=access_chain_bases.end()) + id = i->second; + Variable &var = variables[id]; + auto j = find(current_block->accessed_variables, &var); + if(j==current_block->accessed_variables.end()) + current_block->accessed_variables.push_back(&var); + } +} + +void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_access_chain(CodeIterator op) +{ + access_chain_bases[*(op+2)] = *(op+3); +} + void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_decorate(CodeIterator op) { unsigned id = *(op+1); @@ -509,11 +778,14 @@ void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_decorate(CodeIterator op) switch(decoration) { case DECO_SPEC_ID: - spec_constants[id].constant_id = *op; + constants[id].constant_id = *op; break; case DECO_ARRAY_STRIDE: types[id].array_stride = *op; break; + case DECO_BUILTIN: + variables[id].builtin = static_cast(*op); + break; case DECO_LOCATION: variables[id].location = *op; break; @@ -541,11 +813,49 @@ void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_member_decorate(CodeIterator op) case DECO_MATRIX_STRIDE: member.matrix_stride = *op; break; + case DECO_BUILTIN: + member.builtin = static_cast(*op); + break; case DECO_OFFSET: member.offset = *op; break; } } +void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_label(CodeIterator op) +{ + unsigned id = *(op+1); + current_block = &blocks[id]; + current_block->id = id; +} + +void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_branch(CodeIterator op) +{ + InstructionBlock &block = blocks[*(op+1)]; + block.condition = &true_condition; + current_block->successors.push_back(&block); +} + +void SpirVModule::Reflection::reflect_branch_conditional(CodeIterator op) +{ + InstructionBlock &true_block = blocks[*(op+2)]; + InstructionBlock &false_block = blocks[*(op+3)]; + + auto i = constants.find(*(op+1)); + if(i!=constants.end() && i->second.constant_id) + { + if(!true_block.condition) + true_block.condition = &i->second; + if(!false_block.condition) + { + false_block.condition = &i->second; + false_block.negate_condition = true; + } + } + + current_block->successors.push_back(&true_block); + current_block->successors.push_back(&false_block); +} + } // namespace GL } // namespace Msp